Visits

Sunday, May 2, 2010

Being religious could be injurious to your (mental) health

Contrary to popular belief, religion can induce hallucinatory behaviour - please pay careful attention to the following classic symptoms.

[1] You may suspend the usage of your intellect

Normally, you will use this to carefully analyse every decision that you take - for example (a) Painstaking research about which cellphone to buy; (b) Credit history of a guy before lending him money; (c) Studying effectiveness of your earlier advertisements before releasing new ones. When the same person is however in the "religion" mode, he just stops using his analytical ability & allows himself to be lead by the nose, as if in a trance - for example believing that (d) you could be reborn as a dog in the next life; (e) you could absolve yourself of all sins just by confessing or taking a holy dip in a river; (f) certain moments are more auspicious than others.

[2] You may believe that bribery is an acceptable way of getting things done

While there is a stringent law in place against giving, abetting or accepting UTT (popular term amongst sales persons meaning "under the table"), religious people cannot be arrested for doing this, as the other party has never been identified. So you have people offering gold and cash to GOD to get in return, at least a part of their wish list (an offspring, wealth, business, success in an examination or as in Chennai, a mundane visa to USA)

[3] Your obsequious loyalty may reach the heavens (pun intended)

Those of you who have had dogs at home, would easily recall how delightful it is to be welcomed home at any hour with that love lorn look in the eyes of your pet (a spouse is no match except maybe during the first few months of marriage). This is what I call 100% loyalty and yes how you love his groveling for biscuits or whatever... Now just imagine yourself symbolically to be the pet and then start pleading for favours from the supreme entity that religions want you to surrender yourself to. The pet just doesn't know any other way of getting its rewards but human beings do - but would still not make use of any of these alternatives.

[4] Virtual reality cannot get you your daily bread

Psychologists recommend "positive thinking and optimism" as traits that would improve personal productivity but these cannot be used to acquire hardcore skills like flying an aircraft or becoming a surgeon. An interesting research has demonstrated that predominantly "atheist" nations (large enough statistical samples) far outclass "religious minded" ones on every parameter of economic development like GDP growth, improvement in health standards, reduction of poverty, empowerment of women, reduction in child mortality etc. The reason looks obvious: while the atheists have no one to "fall back upon except themselves" to perform, others depend on GOD to do most of their chores.

[5] Your fear of the unknown will increase manifold

Do ghosts frighten you? Are you fearful that all your actions are being entered in a balance sheet by someone who will one day (conveniently after your death) ask you to explain and then allot you an abode that is commensurate with your net positive (or negative) worth? Have you convinced yourself that our solar system and other galaxies cannot but be controlled by some "powerful entity" (read GOD)? The major strength of any religion is that it cleverly operates on the basis of hypotheses that cannot be disproved. Moreover, anything that cannot be explained is attributed to that supreme power. Now how many discoveries in the last century (which were earlier attributed to the divine power) were indeed found to be so? ZERO! All that has happened is that a new set of unknown things are now attributed to the divine power. The burden of proving any theory normally lies on the one who propounds it - here it is exactly the opposite - the burden of disproving it lies on the non - believer and until that happens, the believer happily keeps behaving as if it was the ultimate truth. Religion instills such an acute fear of ostracism amongst its followers that most of them turn completely robotic and pliant.

[6] You will stop expecting "accountability" from others

This is natural because religion is not at all accountable for whatever it promises and still has no "customer dissatisfaction" (to use a marketing term). Imagine that you bought an air-conditioner which did not cool your room. Will you blame your ill - luck and just go to the same shop and buy another one hoping that it will work this time? Religion expects you to keep doing that until "one of the units does cool your room" - then it turns around and tells you - "see I intervened with the the shopkeeper to give you a working piece ". It remains completely silent on why it did not intervene all these months - and you of course are so grateful and overjoyed at having got the right AC that you now start praying for a car.


Religious preachers never tire of quoting how flowing water is purer than stagnant water. In the last few thousand years, there hasn't been a single new thought added to religious philosophy (stagnant) while the world outside has innovated in leaps and bounds (running water). Neither its preachers nor its scriptures are likely to withstand rigorous and independent scrutiny - a threshold that any philosophy has to cross to earn its stars. Human beings must have got genetically mis-wired (some software somewhere got mis programmed in the process of evolution) for so many of them to behave in the weird manner that they do when it comes to "religion".

It would actually be a good idea to post a statutory warning outside all places of worship that says " Beware! Entering may increase delusional behaviour"

4 comments:

Dr Ravi Shivde said...

Dear Sir,

It is heartening to read your messages. Rationalists are rare to find indeed, in this madhouse of godmen that our country has come to.

Swapnil Shukla said...

Yes Sir, may be you are right when it goes "being religious could be injurious to your (mental)health. But is it really true?

What if a person tries several times and fails.. again tries and again fails.. prays to god and gets mental satisfaction that there is someone with him. Then he tries and succeeds.. isn't it "not injurious" considering the fact that he tried and succeeded and added value to the nation/society/academics instead of just being rational and losing hope?

Pre-historic cases of fiction do govern this land even today.

After all what is "today?" Isn't it fiction too? In case the moon's distance from earth was just some kilometers closer or farther, life would have been impossible on earth. The inclination of the earth's axis was tilted even 1 degree on either side, there wouldn't have been seasons and life on earth would have been impossible. Our moon is filled with marks of meteor strikes but has it been a common feature on earth?

Aren't these some of those many reasons which make man believe that there is some supreme power which takes care of him?

Man-kind through its evolution has been thinking about all this damn seriously. Thus it is but natural on his part to be religious. And there is nothing wrong in praying up an extent which will increase your performance.

The problem starts when man gets into the habit of praying and starts demanding everything through his prayers.

- Swapnil Shukla

Darshan Chande said...

This is excellent. I am finding much interesting articles on your blog which would help me to get points to put in my arguments / debates in favor of atheism.

There's a lot of truth in each one of them. Wonder why fat-headed god-believers can't see the obvious! Yeah, the weakness of spirit!

I would like you to read my article What is God? (Click) on my blog.

Thank you.

Amol said...

I think what Swapnil is saying is " surrendering to a higher Power & asking for blessings". Nothing wrong in it. In fact it is difficult because to surrender truly , one has to let go the EGO.

If we notice,there is a something beyond the mind & the intellect. It is so obvious. Now,on the level of mind there are so many opinions & conflicts & agreements. Constantly thinking is injurious to mental health. We become so tired.

Blindly & selfishly following religion is foolish. But are we going to ignore the wisdom of Saints like Kabir, Tukaram ,Vivekananda? Do we consider ourselves as intellectuals, Rationalists to the extent that we miss out the teachings of Advaita Vedanta,Upanishads or the Bhagavad Gita? We might gain material wealth (the west has ) but will loose the Bliss & Ecstasy of Human Life.