Visits

Monday, May 24, 2010

What is wrong with us?

Three happenings in the recent past have saddened me as I am sure they have, countless other fellow Indians. The way India managed and weathered the last two years of economic recession and the brightness with which many non resident Indians are shining all over the globe had for once given credence to Dr. Kalams' dream of our country getting counted as a role model (albeit in the next few decades). These events certainly deflated that pride.

1. खाप Panchayats in Haryana:

In obviously what is a no brainer, "same - गोत्र " marriages cannot lead to genetic defects that could occur in off-springs (due to "in-breeding") because of the simple fact that the present generation is very far removed from the original ऋषी (the name of the gotra is the same as that of this sage) from whom the lineage started. These खाप पंचायत in Haryana are ordering newly married couples to be ostracized or even killed for not obeying their ridiculous diktats of not marrying someone staying in even the same village. What is more disturbing is that there is no up surge of anger amongst Haryanvis who otherwise are hot-blooded enough to spill their anger on the streets. To top it all, two Members of Parliament (one of them Mr Jindal who is a part of India's progressive youth brigade) have come out with meaningless and mushy statements (obviously keeping their vote banks in mind) about how we must respect our traditions. Frankly I am perplexed - can India shine brightly with a prosperous state like Haryana being so outdated and callous in its public beliefs? Or is this a new strategy to give a scientific flavour to what essentially is superstitious nonsense or at best illegal flexing of political muscles. Who knows, we may next have a demand from Rajasthan to re start the practice of "सती "?

2. Antics of Shibu Soren in Jharkand

He becomes Chief Minister with BJP's support - then goes and votes against them in the no confidence motion against the Congress government at Delhi - asks for forgiveness when BJP threatens to withdraw support in Jharkand - first agrees to step down and allow BJP to form the government with its own CM - then turns around and says both parties will have CM by rotation for 28 months each and finally says he won't vacate the seat for the BJP. What surprises me is the absolutely spineless response of a national party like BJP just for sharing the spoils of office. If the "Hindutva" brigade cannot shun मोह (lust for power in this case) which Hinduism calls upon its true followers to achieve, aren't they being as hypocritical as they accuse their opponents to be?

3. फतवा from Deoband about not working in banking and insurance sectors.

The presumptious फतवा about Muslims not being allowed to work in both these sectors (because it is against the shariah) is another ridiculous attempt to impose fake religiosity over the common masses who understandably dare not openly criticize these interpreters of faith. There were some sporadic public calls from other Muslim clerics about the non tenability of this फतवा but what remains etched in the mind is the threat received by Mr. Javed Akhtar (may his tribe grow) who is the only Muslim atheist that I have ever heard of.

Don't you think India is moving back to medieval ages, at supersonic speed??

3 comments:

Swapnil Shukla said...

Sir, I humbly disagree with you. The 3 instances presented by you emerge from an under-developed / developing parts of India. The media coverage has spread its wings to cover every nooks and corners now. Such instances were always going on and will go on. We have to take in to account the percentage coverage of such happenings. Also avoidance of such instances in future should be ensured.

regards,

Swapnil

Suman Bose said...

I think that we should not see too much of ourselves as a model nation. Lets take the profecies of Dr. APJ Kalam with a pinch of salt. In fact we do not deserve any such coveted lofty positions. India will continue to be India with all its contradictions and controvercies.
But I am sure many can see how our supreme court is leading the fight for change in society. Khap panchayat, same sex marriage, live-in relationship, in all of this the Supreme Court has broken barriers, permitted open discussion and allowed freedom and relief for the citizens of this country. Thats great by any world standards isn't it?

Ankur Shrivastav said...

Sir, I agree with these social black spots which you have mentioned. It is really very disappointing to face these major pitfalls of our society. If we observe there is a common root cause of these problems that is fanaticism in people about there own religion and sense of materialism which has held them into its tight grip. A strict action should be taken against those people who follow their self made parallel courts. If a particular community doesn't follow constitutional rules and instructions given by the Supreme court it should be barred from choosing there MP or Leader, there should be some strict law which makes politicians think beyond their vote banks. Apart from this a sense of spirituality should be instilled into the people by some innovative means which should explain them the importance of equality, but it happens by choice not by force. As we will move on generations after generations a day will come when these narrow minded people will die and the new educated generation will discard these superstitious rules made by uneducated LITERATE society.